|
Somewhere between the Blue Ridge and Allegheny mountains,
a country road exits the busy interstate and winds its way past
the occasional abandoned farmhouse, through the sleepy Appalachian
hills. This rural pocket of Southwest Virginia seems generations
removed from any information superhighway.
But then the country road turns abruptly into the town of
Blacksburg, where no sign of the information age could be more
obvious than the URL -- http://www.bev.net -- prominently displayed
on the town's municipal building.
Welcome to Blacksburg Electronic
Village, where main street meets cyberspace.
For the past four years, Blacksburg has been engaged in a
giant experiment to get the entire town online -- citizens, schools,
local government, and community groups. The result has become
a unique laboratory where researchers from a variety of disciplines
are having a field day analyzing the impact of computer network
technology on learning and living.
Blacksburg is not exactly a typical town. Home to Virginia
Tech, the state's largest university, Blacksburg is a high-tech
enclave in a rural setting of relative poverty and isolation.
But the technological ripple effects of Blacksburg Electronic
Village (BEV) -- a cooperative effort between Virginia
Tech, Bell Atlantic,
and the town of Blacksburg
-- are spreading throughout surrounding Montgomery County.
The county's school system
is a prime beneficiary of this ripple effect. Today, all 21 schools
in the 9,000-student district enjoy high-speed connections to
the Internet, thanks in large part to the technological leverage
provided by Virginia Tech and Bell Atlantic. Nine county schools
are hooked up to T-1 lines, and the remainder are connected via
ISDN, networking a total of more than 1,400 personal computers
in the school system.
"Our charter is to get people connected, and schools
are an important part of the community," says BEV's director,
Andrew Michael Cohill. "BEV was able to get network access
for Blacksburg-area schools much sooner than they would have
been able to do it by themselves."
But it's not just the schools that are wired: Roughly half
of Montgomery
County's 75,000 residents are online, too, completing the
school-community communication loop. Parents, teachers, administrators,
and school board members regularly communicate with each other
using e-mail. One board member even sends out an e-mail newsletter
to more than 400 constituents.
As an incentive to get residents online, BEV offers free e-mail
accounts to Blacksburg citizens, and public access to the network
is available at no cost in several branches of the county library.
The demand for online time is such that currently at least eight
Internet service providers have set up shop in town and are doing
a brisk business selling dial-up access.
Virginia Tech faculty, staff, and students -- who account
for 30,000 of Blacksburg's 36,000 citizens -- can also get online
by means of direct connections on campus or by using the university's
modem pool to connect from home. But the truly lucky live in
one of the six local apartment complexes that have been wired
with direct T-1 Internet connections to Ethernet ports in the
apartment units. About 70 businesses in town are hooked up the
same way.
Meanwhile, information provided by the town government, schools,
community organizations, churches, and more than 300 businesses
can be accessed from a bevy of local web sites that are hosted
on BEV's own web server and on 100 other web servers in the area.
BEV has brought the world to Blacksburg. But that's not all:
Having inspired a critical mass of people to get online, it has
also opened new channels of communication within the community.
Indeed, this ambitious experiment in community networking is
as much a project about people as it is about technology. And
for schools throughout Montgomery County, that's good news.
Leveraging the network
"Three years ago, we had very few local-area networks
in the school system, and there was no wide-area network,"
says Larry Arrington, the district's soft-spoken supervisor of
technology. "Then Bell Atlantic came in and said, 'We'll
give you four T-1 lines.'"
To make the best use of this technological windfall, the district
drafted a technology plan, upgraded its local network infrastructure,
and replaced its outdated personal computers with modern, powerful
PCs and Macs. Today, the district employs a technology staff
of 11 people, eight of whom spend all their time on maintenance.
The high-speed networking and new computers that are now in
place are paying off in the classroom.
"BEV has given us the springboard -- almost a rocket
launcher -- to go from," says Jon Utin, who teaches sixth-grade
math and science at Blacksburg
Middle School. "I feel an obligation to teach them about
technology and the Internet. This is their future."
Utin's classroom, a former machine shop, is a warm and open
space that he has almost single-handedly converted into an extraordinary
combination zoology/technology laboratory. Macs linked to a T-1
connection are lined up against one wall; across the large room,
king-size goldfish swim placidly in a homemade aquarium the size
of a small pond. It's late afternoon on a Friday, but his students
are working intently on their class home page.
Utin's students use the Internet to participate in several
online curriculum projects, including Kids
as Global Scientists, a program in which teams of students
all over the world collaborate on inquiry-based weather analysis.
The fact that he can communicate with most of his students' parents
via e-mail actually means less work for him, Utin says, because
both parties can send and receive messages when it's convenient
for them. Chasing down a parent on the phone can be a time-consuming
task, he says.
Beyond such day-to-day instructional benefits, the district
is making the most of its partnership with BEV by collaborating
with Virginia Tech on several research projects that are generating
data about the impact of networked technology on classroom learning.
One such ongoing project is Learning
in Networked Communities (LiNC), which is funded by a $1.1
million National Science Foundation grant. LiNC is designed to
allow students at four district schools with T-1 connections
-- two in Blacksburg and two in a rural part of the county --
to use the Internet for simultaneous online collaborations.
Starting this fall, students will be conducting physics experiments
in an Internet-based virtual laboratory using Java software applications
written by Virginia Tech graduate students.
"If I am working in this shared virtual lab workspace
and leave, you can enter later and continue the experiment,"
says John M. Carroll, head of the Virginia Tech computer science
department and the project's lead researcher.
The project also gives the researchers an opportunity to study
the students' interactions as 12th-graders develop online mentoring
relationships with eighth-graders living in a different part
of the county.
"This district has pockets of really-haves and pockets
of really-have-nots," Arrington points out. Indeed, 33 percent
of students in the school system qualify to receive free and
reduced-price lunches.
"The trouble with rural schools is that the kids can't
get the courses they need because the teachers don't have the
resources," he adds. By connecting students with disparate
backgrounds in a virtual laboratory setting, the LiNC project
shows how the Internet can be used to afford kids in rural areas
equal opportunities for scientific inquiry and collaboration.
Homestead high-tech
Drive south from Blacksburg for half an hour and you'll reach
Riner, a small and picturesque rural community in the southwest
corner of Montgomery County. Riner's slower pace and natural
beauty is attracting a growing bedroom community of professionals,
many of whom work in Blacksburg. Farming is still the most common
way of life here, though, and the majority of the 320 students
who attend Riner Elementary
School come from families with limited means.
But step inside one of the portable classrooms that have been
added to cope with the school's increasing enrollment, and you'll
see something remarkable: Twenty-four fifth-graders, working
in pairs, share a dozen brand-new Pentium-based PCs with Windows
95 and Internet access provided by a T-1 line. It's a bright
and inviting classroom, with pale gray furniture and carpet chosen
to help the computers blend into the classroom environment. Each
computer has dual keyboards and a switch that allows the students
to use either keyboard; remarkably, they never argue over whose
turn is next.
These students use the Internet as an integrated part of a
curriculum designed to encourage reading, writing, exploration,
collaboration, and critical analysis. They also have access to
a digital camera and scanner and use a web-based computer bulletin
board for online discussions. A real-time online chat environment
is planned, too.
And that's just half the story.
Funded by a $700,000 U.S. Department of Education grant, this
research project has been nicknamed "PCs
for Families" because the students in this special classroom
are also provided with identical PCs to take home. The idea is
for the entire family to benefit from dial-up Internet access
and e-mail.
A conversation over a cup of coffee is what got the ball rolling,
says Melissa Matusevich, the school district's instructional
coordinator. She recalls sitting at a local cafe a few years
ago with Roger Ehrich, a Virginia Tech computer science professor,
when the idea struck her.
"I told Roger I'd like to take an entire classroom, provide
all the kids with computers both at school and at home, and network
everything together, making the technology a seamless support
for a teacher running a constructivist classroom," Matusevich
explains. "E-mail would allow better home-school communication,
and students could learn to use the Internet as part of their
repertoire of resources."
Ehrich supported the idea enthusiastically, and the two joined
forces with Riner's principal, Keith Rowland, to implement the
project. Every parent with a child in the fifth grade wanted
to participate, so the school used a lottery to select the 24
students in the program.
To evaluate the program, BEV researchers will follow three
consecutive classes through fifth, sixth, and seventh grade and
compare their achievement levels against similar students elsewhere
in the school system. The aim is to determine whether, under
the best of circumstances, access to networked computing by both
students and their families has a measurable effect on long-term
student achievement. The project is now starting its second year,
and by all accounts, the results so far are encouraging.
Perhaps the most striking initial finding is that the computers
have become a positive and cohesive force for many of the families.
"The computers became a rallying point for the family. It
became a family activity," Ehrich says.
"Some of the families told stories of being brought closer
together," adds Matusevich, who is writing a dissertation
on the project's effects in the home and the learning environment.
"The computer became a catalyst in the family."
One family told the researchers about the fifth-grader holding
his little brother in his lap, teaching him the letters of the
alphabet on the computer and how to press the keys. Another family
related how the son worked laboriously on a PowerPoint homework
presentation for hours; when the computer broke down and he lost
his work, they all shared in his frustration.
One girl in the program fell in love with her computer and
developed new self-confidence in school. When family troubles
prompted her mother to move out of the school district with her
daughter, Rowland recalls, the girl was simply devastated.
"Her mother was living in a home where there were some
problems, and she'd decided to move out," he says. "When
she called me and told me she was going to have to return the
computer, the girl cried and cried. This computer was the best
thing that had happened to this girl in school, and she didn't
want to leave the program. Finally, her mom called me back and
said she'd decided to move back in and work their problems out.
'Whatever it takes, we're willing to make the sacrifice,' she
said."
Inside the classroom, it's easy to see why the kids feel so
strongly about the program. On the day Electronic School
came to visit, the students were working quietly and independently
with expert guidance from teacher Susan Hood, composing e-mail
to a teacher who had given them a presentation about DNA.
"Brandon is really enthusiastic about school now,"
says Wilma Smith, a school lunch aide whose son is in the program.
"He hardly ever watches TV now -- he's on the computer instead.
There's no problem getting him to do his homework, and e-mail
makes it easier to contact his teachers. We were so excited to
get that computer home."
There have been obstacles and disappointments, of course,
including some practical issues discovered when installing the
computers in students' homes.
"Many of the houses had very poor wiring and lots of
telephone line noise, and we had to upgrade their phone system
in order to be able to use the modem," Rowland says. "Three
families did not even have telephones prior to participating
in the program. The grant now provides phone service for those
families."
A Virginia Tech graduate student provides technical support
for the project's computers, but he's gotten stuck on the rutted
rural roads several times driving to the homes of some of the
participating families. "He's had to have tow trucks come
and pull him out of places," Rowland adds.
Also, some of the parents were reluctant to use e-mail and
a web-based computer bulletin board to communicate with the school.
One man told Matusevich that his daughter would admonish him
to read his e-mail, but he admitted he still hadn't done so.
"Some families have not held up their end of the agreement,
such as attending parent training workshops, filling out surveys,
and making sure that the child has first access to the computer
at home," Rowland says. "Older brothers and sisters
and even parents have in some cases been hogging the computer."
Nonetheless, the project appears to be a success. "Near
the end of the year, these kids were becoming very self-confident
about their abilities," Ehrich says. It's too soon to tell
whether that increased confidence will result in greater achievement,
but with about 25 dissertations under way on the Riner project
alone, it's safe to say that nothing that happens to these kids
is likely to be overlooked.
Networked future
Sitting in front of a Mac in his tastefully designed office,
BEV Director Andrew Michael Cohill is surveying a neat array
of notepad paper on his desk and contemplating the future of
community networks.
"We think fiber to the home is viable today," he
says. "We're going to do that in Blacksburg on a large scale.
It will take 20 years or more to deploy the entire vision, but
BEV will continue to serve as a testbed." The rollout of
a fiber optic network starts downtown and in a residential neighborhood
next year. But the poor, rural parts of the county dotted with
house trailers won't be left behind, Cohill promises.
"Actually, fiber to the trailer isn't as outlandish as
it sounds," he says, pointing out that trailer parks offer
beneficial economies of scale because they are high-density communities.
"It's not always the case that the poor are going to be
underserved. The cost of wiring houses on big lots is higher
than wiring trailer parks. The real key in trying to address
universal access is the willingness to be innovative."
BEV will also continue to research the network's impact on
the community, including schools. Future goals include opening
up all computer labs in the county schools as free network access
points to parents and community members on designated days. Auburn High and Middle School,
located just a stone's throw from Riner Elementary School, has
already opened its computer lab to parents.
"It's a way to gain public support and give back to the
community, so people can't say, 'There's nothing for me there,'"
says Andrea Kavanaugh, BEV's research director.
BEV is also working with other communities to help them start
their own electronic villages. The nearby towns of Abingdon
and Radford are well
on their way, as is Craig County, and this is just in Virginia.
Similar projects are beginning to appear in other parts of the
country, too.
Ultimately, the goal of a community network is to help people
communicate with each other better, Cohill says.
"The network lets people feel less isolated; it doesn't
replace face-to-face communications, it supplements it. The real
value of the network, I think, is that we can all tell our own
story. We can get our voices back."
Lars
Kongshem is an associate editor and
webmaster of Electronic School and The American School Board Journal.
Photography by Lars Kongshem
|